top of page

Why Selling on May Not Be Ideal: Understanding User Discontent

Introduction, known for its unique and handmade items, has long been a popular platform for independent sellers. However, recent trends and user experiences suggest that selling on Etsy might not be as rosy as it seems. This blog post delves into the reasons why Etsy may not be the best choice for sellers and explores the common challenges faced by its users.

The Challenges of Selling on Etsy

  1. Overcrowded Marketplace: With the rise in sellers, Etsy's marketplace has become saturated, making it difficult for new sellers to stand out.

  2. High Fees and Charges: Etsy charges listing fees, transaction fees, and payment processing fees, which can significantly cut into sellers' profits.

  3. Limited Customization and Branding: Sellers often struggle with limited options for store customization, hindering their ability to establish a distinct brand identity.

  4. Algorithm-Driven Visibility: Dependence on Etsy's algorithm for product visibility can lead to unpredictable and inconsistent traffic to sellers' stores.

  5. Competitive Pricing Pressure: The presence of a large number of sellers leads to competitive pricing, often forcing sellers to lower prices unsustainably.

  6. Customer Service Challenges: Sellers frequently cite difficulties with Etsy's customer service, especially when resolving disputes or addressing technical issues.

  7. Unjustified Suspensions: Despite your best attempts Etsy has been known to suspend accounts without reason often refusing to give such reasons even when inquired about.

Pros and Cons


  • Wide Reach: Etsy's large customer base can provide significant exposure to sellers.

  • Niche Market: Ideal platform for handmade and unique products.

  • Ease of Use: User-friendly interface for setting up a shop and listing products.


  • High Competition: Difficult to stand out in an overcrowded marketplace.

  • Fees and Charges: Multiple fees can reduce profitability.

  • Limited Control: Sellers have little control over store functionality and policies.

  • Dependence on Algorithm: Sales heavily depend on Etsy's search algorithm.

  • Customer Service Issues: Limited support in resolving seller issues.

Web Ratings

  • User Satisfaction: 3.5/5 - Based on seller reviews discussing challenges and successes.

  • Ease of Use: 4/5 - For its user-friendly shop setup and management.

  • Profitability: 2.5/5 - Reflecting the impact of fees and competition on earnings.

  • Customer Support: 2/5 - Indicating dissatisfaction with the level of seller support.


  1. Why is it hard to make a profit on Etsy?

  • High competition and fees can significantly reduce profit margins.

  1. Can new sellers succeed on Etsy?

  • Success is possible but challenging due to market saturation and reliance on the search algorithm.

  1. Are there alternatives to Etsy for selling handmade items?

  • Yes, platforms like Shopify, eBay, and local craft markets offer alternatives.

  1. How do Etsy's fees impact sellers?

  • Fees can take a substantial portion of earnings, especially for low-priced items.

  1. Is customer service a significant issue for Etsy sellers?

  • Many sellers report frustrations with resolving issues through Etsy's customer service.

  1. How important is product visibility on Etsy?

  • Crucial for sales, as visibility is heavily influenced by Etsy's search algorithm.

  1. Can sellers build a brand on Etsy?

  • Branding opportunities are limited due to the platform's restrictive customization options.

  1. What challenges do sellers face with the Etsy algorithm?

  • Inconsistent visibility and changes in algorithm can affect store traffic unpredictably.

  1. Is Etsy suitable for all types of products?

  • Etsy is best suited for handmade, vintage, and unique items.

  1. What are the common complaints from Etsy sellers?

  • High fees, competitive market, limited support, and algorithm dependence.

While Etsy offers a platform for creative and unique products, the challenges such as high competition, fees, and limited seller support make it a less ideal option for many. Understanding these drawbacks is crucial for anyone considering selling on Etsy.

Unjustified Account Suspensions: A Growing Concern

One of the most critical and often unaddressed issues facing Etsy sellers is the platform's practice of suspending accounts, sometimes seemingly without a valid reason. This section delves into this significant problem, its impact on sellers, and the lack of transparency in Etsy's suspension policies.

Understanding Etsy's Account Suspension

  • Policy Enforcement: Etsy has a set of guidelines and policies for sellers. However, there have been numerous reports of Etsy suspending accounts without clear explanations or for reasons that sellers find perplexing or unjustified.

  • Impact on Sellers: The suspension of an Etsy account can have a devastating effect, especially for those who rely on the platform as their primary source of income. It not only halts current sales but can also damage a seller's reputation and future business prospects.

  • Communication and Support Issues: Sellers often report frustration with the lack of clear communication from Etsy following a suspension. The process to appeal or even understand the suspension is often described as complicated and lacking transparency.

Seller Experiences and Testimonials

  • Case Studies: Real-life examples of sellers who have had their accounts suspended, detailing their experiences, the reasons provided by Etsy (if any), and the outcome of their appeals.

  • Community Feedback: Highlighting discussions from Etsy forums and social media, where sellers express their concerns and share experiences related to account suspensions.

Evaluating Etsy's Policies

  • Lack of Transparency: A critical look at how Etsy communicates its policies and decisions regarding account suspensions, suggesting areas for improvement in transparency and fairness.

  • Comparative Analysis: Comparing Etsy's account suspension policies and practices with those of other online marketplaces, to understand industry standards and practices.

Advice for Sellers

  • Preventive Measures: Tips for sellers to avoid actions that might lead to account suspension, including adhering to Etsy's guidelines and regularly updating their knowledge of the platform's policies.

  • Handling Suspensions: Guidelines on what steps to take if a seller's account is suspended, including how to communicate effectively with Etsy and navigate the appeal process.


The issue of account suspensions, often with little to no clear justification, is a significant concern for Etsy sellers. It highlights the need for greater transparency and fairness in Etsy's policy enforcement. Understanding and navigating these challenges is crucial for sellers on the platform.

12 views0 comments


bottom of page